A common theme of fan fiction is the "What would happen if..." theme. I've noticed this especially in Lord of the Rings fan fiction. It's also on somewhat of a similar vein to Mary-Sue fan fiction as many people like to do the typical "What would happen if my friends and I were magically transported to Middle Earth?" storyline. Other common "What would happen if..." story lines include "What would happen if there were a 1oth member to the Fellowship?" To be honest, I don't read a lot of this type of fan fictions. I can be as anti-canon as the next person, but there are limits to how anti-canon I am. I don't particularly like stories that throw people from current times into stories set in not current universes. It just doesn't seem right to me to have people talking about cars and the Internet in a Lord of the Rings fan fiction because Lord of the Rings is supposed to have been set eons ago. (I know, it's also odd for a girl who's a fan of Back to the Future to not like time travel stories, but whatever). I can't quite put my finger on why I dislike this specific type; possibly it's because this theme is overdone, or possibly because the few I have read simply retell the story.
And that's my point of the day. I'm sure there are great stories that throw people from current time into the Lord of the Rings universe somewhere out there (if anyone knows of any, please let me know!), but when they just retell the story, honestly, what's the point of reading them? The whole point of fan fiction is to develop your own ideas of something that could happen and use these characters (and some of your own if you like) to tell it.
This concept is different from a story that takes an event that occurred in one of the books (or movies) and shows it through someone else's eyes, for example: the events of what happened in Bree where the four hobbits meet up with Aragorn told through Aragorn's eyes. This is different because, though the scene has occurred in the story, we didn't see it from Aragorn's point of view. It's someone's idea of what Aragorn might have been thinking. It may contain minimal dialogue copied from that scene to get the story going or end it, but it's mostly description; it's mostly Aragorn's thoughts, what he was thinking while watching the hobbits.
A story that simply retells the story of Lord of the Rings with one minor change, is just redundant, actually comes very close to copyright infringement and is another reason why many authors (and others) have issues with fan fiction; because people are taking (near) their exact words and ideas and passing them off as their own. And that's the kind of stuff that give fan fiction a bad name.
Despite my mixed feelings towards throwing characters from current times into Lord of the Rings, there's really nothing wrong with it as long as you do it appropriately. Meaning,
COME UP WITH YOUR OWN REASONS FOR PUTTING THESE CHARACTERS THERE! If you want your character to be part of the Fellowship, fine, just, maybe invent another world-saving quest for them to go on where your character is the one who everything depends on, not Frodo, don't just make them the 10th member of Frodo's quest. If you want Legolas to fall madly in love with your character, perhaps have him meet her (or him, depending) before or after Leoglas goes on the quest. Or even nix the time travel idea and just make your character into an elf who's lived in Middle Earth all along (rather than a story I tried to read where 3 girls from present day were sucked into Middle Earth and turned into elves). You can still be you falling in love with Legolas even if you change the time period you're living in. Time travel stories are difficult ones to write and still keep true to the story without sounding childish. If you're going to do one, just please make up your own idea. The Lord of the Rings trilogy has already been written, thanks. If you're interested in checking out some Lord of the Rings fan fiction, click the link and it'll take you to the
Lord of the Rings page on
fanfiction.net!